The Critical Path /
eMail Newsletter
Provocative Musings for the Irreverent
Product Developer
Issue 7.6 / August 25, 2005
Contents:
-
A Space-Time
Theory of Time-to-Market
<read>
-
HyperLinks: Strange New Products <read>
- Top Ten
Signs You've Outsourced Design to the Wrong
Supplier <read>
- MRT NewsBriefs
<read>
- Calendar of Events
<read>
A
Space-Time Theory of Time-to-Market
Have
you ever wondered why many vacations seem unfulfilling? My idea of a
perfect vacation is one where I can pause the universe’s passing of
time while moving forward on a separate “vacation clock” and then,
upon return, resume life from where I left off.
One of the biggest problems with vacation is that while you are
gone, your actual life continues with no regard to your need for
time off. Bills still need to be paid, world events continue to
occur, and all of your projects at work compile until your return.
Many people who scramble for email access while on holiday often do
so just to keep the inbox load level under control.
If we could somehow control space-time and change its linear nature,
maybe I could make my dream vacation a reality, but for now, it’s
just a pipe-dream.
Product development projects run along their own “space-time,” a
group of dimensions that combine a linear path of physical and
temporal phenomena. There are often times within a project where we
wish we had the ability to pause one part and proceed on the other,
just like my vacation fantasy, but are limited by the fact that many
things are interconnected like contestants in a three-legged race at
a father-son picnic.
One way to divide the space-time of development projects is by its
physical development and its conceptual development. Physical
development tasks are the “spatial” dimensions that can be measured,
and are composed of the engineering and manufacturing of the
physical parts and materials that make up the product. The
conceptual development is the “time” dimension composed of things
that are immeasurable, and represents the ideas behind the product,
who it’s for, what it does, requirement specifications, how it will
be differentiated in the market, creative work and other concepts.
Connect these dimensions as a linear path towards a product launch
and together you can say that the space-time cycle of idea to
implementation represents “time-to-market.”
What this otherwise useless intellectual exercise allows us to do is
view product development from an alternative deconstructive
perspective to try and expose areas that can help us accomplish
project goals and shorten cycle time.
The “critical path” (from which this newsletter draws its moniker)
is another term that can be used to represent the entire project as
a combination of interdependent events. Many product development
experts advise that such things as new technology development be
removed from the critical path to prevent the new technology’s
slower developmental timeline from interfering with the overall
project’s schedule. This could be called “concurrent engineering” or
“parallel processing,” but is also a method for altering the
space-time of a project.
If you really want to take this analogy further, you can say that
everything within a project, tasks, decisions, CAD procedures,
testing, etc., all emit strong or weak forces upon the project. They
each have a level of “gravity” that can push or pull on one another,
thus affecting each other’s path in project space-time. Some
management decisions definitely bend space or create dips that pull
the project in a particular direction, just as massive heavenly
bodies do to the fabric of the universe.
For example, let’s say you are trying to determine what type of
material to use for the casing of a piece of your product. You know
that one senior manager has a strong bias towards a particular type
of polycarbonate plastic, so the strength of his gravitational force
will pull this decision towards a particular materials path that
will dictate that portion of the project space-time.
Many times such management decisions could be called
“singularities,” which in physics is defined as “a point in
space-time at which gravitational forces cause matter to have
infinite density and infinitesimal volume, and space and time to
become infinitely distorted.” It’s best to minimize project
singularities where possible. If you have more than one singularity
appear in your development system, whether it be scope-creep or an
engineering change order, you can easily see how their gravitational
force can affect time-to-market.
Suffice it to say that every product development project creates its
own big bang, and is like a universe unto itself. But unlike the
cosmic universe, every project universe is encapsulated, bound
within a sphere that has a definable beginning and definite finish
(at least we hope so). And like my vacation example, most
projects seem to march forward on a timeline that lives outside of,
but is always connected to, other universes. If only we could exit
time to work on the project and re-enter the timeline once it was
complete. If only.
In the past, readers have remarked to me that using the metaphors of
the science of physics to describe the product development process
is helpful; others have called it “useless pedantry.” Regardless of
where you fall in this spectrum of opinion on this article, the time
you’ve spent reading it, you can’t have back. The same goes for all
of your projects. Damn you, Einstein!

HyperLinks:
Strange New Products
Recently we’ve pointed you to gadget
‘blog’ sites like Gizmodo and
Engadget that provide daily
reports on both cool and weird, mostly high-tech devices, from both
mainstream sources and stuff that seemingly originates from under
one of the world’s many rocks.
In this issue, we follow this same road,
but take a jaunt down some side streets to a website focused less on
the gadgets and more on the weird. By the site’s own admission, the
Strange New Products website “is about stuff that is totally
revolutionary, really weird, corny, ingenious, or completely
useless.” If you suspect this describes things in your company’s
product portfolio, you might want to visit.
This site reminds us highly of the work
of
Robert McMath, a “new products” guru who boasts a collection of
over 80,000 consumer goods, mostly market failures. Truly, McMath’s
favorites like “garlic cake” and “monster repellent spray” would fit
right in on Strange New Products. Some of their recent entries
include:
(A Top Ten Classic from
05-16-01)
Top Ten
Signs
You've Outsourced Design to the Wrong Supplier
From the MRT satellite office in Palo Alto, CA
| 10. |
All of
their brainstorming exercises involve nudity |
9. |
When
you visit their office, not one person is dressed in black |
8. |
You ask them for color specs and they
mail you a couple of crayons |
| 7. |
They
continually miss deadlines because their staff "felt sleepy" |
|
6. |
Never
once questions whether incontinence products really need translucent
colored plastics |
| 5. |
They go
out to stores to purchase competitive products, but come back with a
big bag of "magic beans" |
| 4. |
They
promise something "insanely great," but are only half right
|
| 3. |
They
use same rationale for every design decision: "chicks dig it" |
| 2. |
During
focus groups, they ask each participant for a urine sample, lock of
hair and a toenail clipping |
|
...and the No. 1 Sign You've
Outsourced Design to the Wrong Supplier: |
| 1. |
Five
words: "But that's NOT a prototype." |
|
Top
Ten List Archive
MRT NewsBriefs
Everyone who attends MRT’s Annual Conference
on Voice of the Customer can get up to three free books, just by showing
up. The free books are:
1. “Democratizing Innovation,” by Eric von Hippel
2. “Customer Centric Product Definition,” by Sheila Mello
3. “Lean Design Solution,” by Bart Huthwaite
For details on how to
redeem this offer:
http://www.managementroundtable.com/Event_Center/VOC05/VOC05_specialfeatures.html
Thanks
to everyone who nominated colleagues for MRT’s first ever “Product
Development and R&D MVP Awards.” Our panel of judges has reviewed
all submissions and winners will be announced shortly. Award recipients
are chosen based on their history of making significant impact on their
company’s ability to produce winning products and their effectiveness in
sharing their knowledge and skills with others. Winners will be honored
and receive award trophies at MRT’s upcoming
10th Annual Metrics Conference.
For more information:
http://www.managementroundtable.com/Event_Center/MET05/MET05_MVP.html
Preliminary details
are now available for the “Fifth
International MRT/PDMA Congress on Co-Developing Products with Partners,
Suppliers and Customers.” Each year Management Roundtable and PDMA
join forces to offer this forum for product developers to network and
learn from each other about dealing with the challenges of partnerships
and alliances. This year will focus on the subject of “Open Innovation.”
The first ten people to register for this event will be invited to a
special luncheon with
Henry Chesbrough and receive a signed copy of his landmark book,
“Open Innovation: The New Imperative for Creating and Profiting from
Technology.”
For more information:
http://www.codevpd.org
MRT
recently announced a new audiosession on “The
CEOs View of Measuring R&D”. Led by Bradford L. Goldense of Goldense
Group, Inc., this session will discuss six separate subject areas where
CEOs look to make sure metrics are actively maintained and monitored.
For more information:
The CEOs View of Measuring R&D / September 14, 1:00-2:30pm ET
http://www.managementroundtable.com/Event_Center/Audiocons/GGI/CEORD-GGI.html
As part of the
promotion for our 10th Annual Conference on Product Development Metrics,
we’ve made the following articles and white papers available for
download:
-
“Metrics—Guide
to Leading Practices” from
Knowledge Roundtable
-
“How do we know
we're measuring the right things? A model for weighing strategic
priorities.”
-
“Using Metrics
to Drive Change: The Evolution of R&D Metrics at National
Semiconductor”
-
“Measuring R&D's
Linkage to Corporate Strategy - It Can Be Done.” Expert commentary
by Brad Goldense, Goldense Group, Inc.
-
White Paper:
"Metrics Thermostat" by John Hauser, MIT Sloan School of Management
To
download .pdf’s of these titles, go to
http://www.pdmetrics.com

Calendar of Events
AudioSessions
Conferences
Workshops
To inquire about exhibit and sponsorship opportunities at
MRT events, please contact Kathy Stewart at
kathy@roundtable.com or by phone at
781-891-8080 x224.
Administrivia
The Critical Path is a free
monthly e-mail newsletter written by:
Gregg Tong
Management Roundtable, Inc.
92 Crescent Street, Waltham, MA 02453 USA
Tel: (781) 891-8080 Fax: (781) 398-1889
Gregg@roundtable.com
Please feel free to forward this publication to any
friends or associates you feel could benefit from its message. We welcome any suggestions,
stories or comments that will help us improve the value of this newsletter. Please contact
me directly with your input at the email address above.
This newsletter and archived issues can be
retrieved directly from our website at the following url: http://www.roundtable.com/Critical_Path/Critical-Path-Index.html
SUBSCRIPTION
INSTRUCTIONS
To begin your FREE subscription, please use the automated form located here or send me an email - gregg@roundtable.com. To
unsubscribe, click the link at the bottom of this page if you received it via
email, otherwise, please send an email to me at gregg@roundtable.com
with "unsubscribe critical path" in the subject line or message body.
NEWSLETTER SPONSORSHIP
The Critical Path is provided free of charge to its readers. Companies that share
our objectives of promoting innovative and thought-provoking product development practices
may sponsor The Critical Path. There is space for a maximum of two sponsor messages per
issue. Please send e-mail to gregg@roundtable.com for a complete list of
sponsorship terms and fees, please click here.
PERMISSION TO REPOST TCP
Applications for permission to make The Critical Path available within a company
or other organization (e.g. by internal mail, corporate Intranet, etc.) are usually
accepted. Please send a request for permission to gregg@roundtable.com
DISCLAIMER
The views, thoughts and opinions expressed in this newsletter are solely those of the
author, and do not reflect the views, thoughts and opinions of Management Roundtable, Inc.
or its affiliates.
For more information on Management Roundtable's
events, publications, and services: http://www.ManagementRoundtable.com
© Copyright 2005 by Management Roundtable, Inc. All rights reserved. |